Isocitrate lyase (ICL) is the first enzyme involved in glyoxylate cycle. Many plants and microorganisms are relying on glyoxylate cycle enzymes to survive upon downregulation of tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA cycle), especially Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB). In fact, ICL is a potential drug target for MTB in dormancy. With the urge for new antitubercular drug to overcome tuberculosis treat such as multidrug resistant strain and HIV-coinfection, the pace of drug discovery has to be increased. There are many approaches to discovering potential inhibitor for MTB ICL and we hereby review the updated list of them. The potential inhibitors can be either a natural compound or synthetic compound. Moreover, these compounds are not necessary to be discovered only from MTB ICL, as it can also be discovered by a non-MTB ICL. Our review is categorized into four sections, namely, (a) MTB ICL with natural compounds; (b) MTB ICL with synthetic compounds; (c) non-MTB ICL with natural compounds; and (d) non-MTB ICL with synthetic compounds. Each of the approaches is capable of overcoming different challenges of inhibitor discovery. We hope that this paper will benefit the discovery of better inhibitor for ICL.
Pulmonary tuberculosis, caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis, is one of the most persistent diseases leading to death in humans. As one of the key targets during the latent/dormant stage of M. tuberculosis, isocitrate lyase (ICL) has been a subject of interest for new tuberculosis therapeutics. In this work, the cleavage of the isocitrate by M. tuberculosis ICL was studied using quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics method at M06-2X/6-31+G(d,p): AMBER level of theory. The electronic embedding approach was applied to provide a better depiction of electrostatic interactions between MM and QM regions. Two possible pathways (pathway I that involves Asp108 and pathway II that involves Glu182) that could lead to the metabolism of isocitrate was studied in this study. The results suggested that the core residues involved in isocitrate catalytic cleavage mechanism are Asp108, Cys191 and Arg228. A water molecule bonded to Mg2+ acts as the catalytic base for the deprotonation of isocitrate C(2)-OH group, while Cys191 acts as the catalytic acid. Our observation suggests that the shuttle proton from isocitrate hydroxyl group C(2) atom is favourably transferred to Asp108 instead of Glu182 with a lower activation energy of 6.2 kcal/mol. Natural bond analysis also demonstrated that pathway I involving the transfer of proton to Asp108 has a higher intermolecular interaction and charge transfer that were associated with higher stabilization energy. The QM/MM transition state stepwise catalytic mechanism of ICL agrees with the in vitro enzymatic assay whereby Asp108Ala and Cys191Ser ICL mutants lost their isocitrate cleavage activities.
Isocitrate lyase (ICL) is a persistent factor for the survival of dormant stage Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB), thus a potential drug target for tuberculosis treatment. In this work, ensemble docking approach was used to screen for potential inhibitors of ICL. The ensemble conformations of ICL active site were obtained from molecular dynamics simulation on three dimer form systems, namely the apo ICL, ICL in complex with metabolites (glyoxylate and succinate), and ICL in complex with substrate (isocitrate). Together with the ensemble conformations and the X-ray crystal structures, 22 structures were used for the screening against Malaysian Natural Compound Database (NADI). The top 10 compounds for each ensemble conformation were selected. The number of compounds was then further narrowed down to 22 compounds that were within the Lipinski's Rule of Five for drug-likeliness and were also docked into more than one ensemble conformation. Theses 22 compounds were furthered evaluate using whole cell assay. Some compounds were not commercially available; therefore, plant crude extracts were used for the whole cell assay. Compared to itaconate (the known inhibitor of ICL), crude extracts from Manilkara zapota, Morinda citrifolia, Vitex negundo, and Momordica charantia showed some inhibition activity. The MIC/MBC value were 12.5/25, 12.5/25, 0.78/1.6, and 0.39/1.6 mg/mL, respectively. This work could serve as a preliminary study in order to narrow the scope for high throughput screening in the future.
Tuberculosis (TB) still remains a global threat due to the emergence of a drug-resistant strain. Instead of focusing on the drug target of active stage TB, we are highlighting the isocitrate lyase (ICL) at the dormant stage TB. ICL is one of the persistent factors for Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) to survive during the dormant phase. In addition, the absence of ICL in human has made ICL a potential drug target for TB therapy. However, the dynamic details of ICL which could give insights to the ICL-ligand interaction have yet to be solved. Therefore, a series of ICL dimer dynamics studies through molecular dynamics simulation were performed in this work. The ICL active site entrance gate closure is contributed to by hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions with the C-terminal. Analysis suggested that the open-closed behavior of the ICL active site entrance depends on the type of ligand present in the active site. We also observed four residues (Ser91, Asp108, Asp153, and Cys191) which could possibly be the nucleophiles for nucleophilic attack on the cleavage of isocitrate at the C2-C3bond. We hope that the elucidation of ICL dynamics can benefit future works such as lead identification or antibody design against ICL for TB therapeutics.