Safety, tolerability and efficacy of LEGA-Kid® mechanical percussion device versus conventional chest physiotherapy in children: a randomised, single-blind controlled study

INTRODUCTION: Chest physiotherapy (CPT) may benefit children aged < 5 years who suffer from lower respiratory tract infection (LRTI). However, its effects are technique-dependent. This study aimed to determine whether mechanical CPT using the LEGA-Kid® mechanical percussion device is superior to manual CPT in children with LRTI.

METHODS: Children aged 5 months to 5 years who were admitted and referred for CPT from January to April 2017 were randomised to either manual CPT or mechanical CPT with LEGA-Kid®. Outcomes measured at pre-intervention and 2 hours post-intervention were respiratory rate (RR), oxygen saturation and modified Respiratory Distress Assessment Instrument (mRDAI) score.

RESULTS: All 30 enrolled patients had significant reduction in post-intervention RR and mRDAI scores. There was an 8% reduction in RR for the manual CPT group (p = 0.002) and a 16.5% reduction in the mechanical CPT group (p = 0.0001), with a significantly greater reduction in the latter (p = 0.024). mRDAI scores decreased by 2.96 in the manual group (p = 0.0001) and 3.62 in the mechanical group (p = 0.002), with no significant difference between the groups. There was no significant improvement in oxygen saturation, and no adverse events were observed after CPT.

CONCLUSION: Children receiving either manual or mechanical CPT showed improvements in respiratory distress symptoms with no adverse effects. A combined strategy of nebulised hypertonic saline followed by CPT for LRTI removes airway secretions and results in improvements of moderately severe respiratory distress. The LEGA-Kid mechanical CPT method was superior in reducing RR.